Thursday, July 2, 2015

Interview: How I Became an Allie and Marriage Equality

I've been interviewed three times: one recording in person and two via email. Here is one where Greg Prince asked how I became involved and my opinions about the LDS Church's influence towards marriage equality for gay couples.

January 20, 2015
1. What brought you into the debate, within Mormon circles, concerning homosexuality and, more specifically, marriage equality?

Background info:
My husband and I joined the LDS Church Jan. '99, Northern Virginia. (I'm from AZ; he's from France).
As far as I know, I have no gay relatives. If any of my friends were gay, I had no idea. I had a gay teacher in high school (AZ), and I didn't understand why classmates made fun of him. The concept of homosexuality, good or bad, was never on my radar. I was also oblivious to how the LDS Church felt about gay people. I had no idea about Prop 8. I was a new Church member, busy having babies, living away from familial help, and having a pilot hubby who was away a lot. I didn't watch the news, either. (I could sing PBS's kids' show theme songs for you, though. -Ha!) At church, I was usually nursing a baby or walking the halls; anti-gay messages would have missed me.

Once in a while over casual conversation, I would hear a member say he "hated" gay people. Once was in Virginia, and then another member in our Illinois ward. I thought it was strong language (Hate? Really?), didn't understand why, but brushed it off as their unique weakness. Then, while also in Illinois, a member and friend came to my door with a petition. She said it was Prop 8 related. I asked what that meant. She said it was a petition to keep gay people from marrying. I kindly told her I was sorry but that I just didn't feel the spirit about that petition, and I won't sign it.

At that time, I thought it was her petition. A month later, I asked her how her petition went. She answered, "Oh, it wasn't my petition. I didn't like doing it." Puzzled, I asked her why she did it. "I was called by the Stake to do it. It was a calling."

My stomach felt sick. Thoughts in my head: My church was interfering with the lives of others? Why? Why would they do something so mean? I thought they weren't political? 

I didn't understand. I also didn't make any effort to go to church for about 2 months (hubby had to work, church was 30 miles away, and toddlers-in-tow aided the decision, also). Eventually I started going back after a member friend told me the prophet knows best and that sometimes what he has to say can be hard to hear but necessary. I wasn't completely convinced, but since I didn't know anything about homosexuality, I thought maybe they knew something I didn't know.

Now to directly answer your question:
(At the time - active Mormon living in American Fork, UT, as of 12/08. TR [temple recommend]-holder. Sunday school teacher for 14-15 y.o. group. Hubby EQ [Elders Quorum] 1st Counselor).
Two years ago, my 13 y.o. son and I were brain-storming Eagle Scout projects he could do. It was late, and I jokingly remarked before retiring to bed, "You should do something to help gay people. I'm SURE the BSA [Boy Scouts of America] would LOVE that!" During this time, the BSA was debating about allowing gay scouts or not. This joke, this idea, stuck. The next day, we discussed it and both thought it was a good idea. But oh-my-goodness, where to start? I began with Mormons Building Bridges and Utah Pride Center. We discovered there was NOTHING in Utah County for gay people...no support groups, anything. Long story short: We decided to begin a Gay Straight Alliance club at American Fork High School. My 13 y.o. was dragging his feet. In the mean time, I was learning about the plight of LDS gay members.  I began meeting and speaking with gay people. I read blog posts, coming out videos, went to a workshop introducing OUTreach Resource Center's Safe and Sound project to help homeless youth (most kicked out of their "loving" LDS homes for being LGBTQ+ --"Wait! What??"), attending workshops about suicide prevention. The more I learned, the more I was pulled in. My.Heart.Broke. Within a couple of weeks of that spring's General Conference session as I was learning about all of this, two local LDS youth died by suicide. One was an AFHS student, and another was an openly gay LDS member (young adult). 

Urgency set in. I took my son's project from him (another reason is the SLTrib was interested in possibly running a story about his ironic project, and my husband and I didn't want him in the media). You can read about our journey here in this relatively short blog: http://myeagleprojectjourney.blogspot.com It has become a "how-to" blog for other schools to start a GSA. It helped Lone Peak HS begin one. I don't know if Timpanogos HS used my blog, but both the Alpine District schools started GSAs a year after ours.

Supporting marriage equality for gay couples followed naturally. I began wearing a rainbow-striped heart-shaped pin to church each week. I bore my testimony of God's and Christ's love for all of his children including his gay children and that we have to be careful what we say from the pulpit because 5-10% of the kids sitting here may be gay. Nobody "chooses" to be gay. What if it's your kid?  -- (You get the picture... I heard I made some people mad that day).

When asked by my bishop and Stake president my position about marriage equality, I told them, "I support the Church's legal right to not have to perform the ceremony but that two consenting, non-related adults (gay or straight) should have the legal right to marry each other, and I should have the right to vote my conscience without fear of losing my temple recommend. If I don't vote my conscience out of fear from the church leaders, then I am in a cult and behaving as a cult member."

2. What have you observed, first-hand, of the Church’s rationale and tactics for justifying and advancing its actions?

I have observed the Church use misinformation about gay people, "The Family: A Proclamation to the World," and the guise of protecting the children/family as their rationale and tactics. I need to add cultish mentality to this, too.

It took me several conversations with members before realizing they have a completely different definition for "gay" than what the actual definition is. I've learned that they think "gay" means having an insatiable appetite for sodomy, and they equate "gay" as being the same thing as pedophilia and bestiality. They lump all those things into the same category. As just one example, when one of my LDS gay friends realized he was gay and sought "help," he was put into a support group of sex addicts and child molesters. He hadn't even held hands with another guy! But the Church mentality is that they are all the same and choose to be so. They also seem to think it's choice made as an adult and that there's no such thing as a gay youth.
-A ward friend was confused when I corrected him to use the term gay instead of SSA. He thought the term gay was considered an insult, that it meant the stereotype (as described above), and that he was just trying to be polite by saying SSA.
-During a Relief Society workshop, a woman stood up and spoke about her husband who was 'suffering' from SSA, "My husband is NOT gay. He just has SSA, and we're going to Northstar to work on it."
-Even when I spoke with Elder Ballard, it appeared that he did not have a clear understanding of what gay meant, either.

When I first read "The Family: A Proclamation to the World" as a new convert, I thought it was beautiful. To me, it was emphasizing the importance of taking conception of children seriously and that they deserve to be cared for. I guess I naively thought it was supporting all kinds of families -- making sure the families have the resources to help raise their children. Just because it spoke about "mother and father," I didn't initially think it was a rejection of gay parents; I thought "mother and father" was a generic term, and my brain substituted "parents," thus, completely overlooking the exclusivity. I have since seen The Proc as an excuse for the Church and loyal members to support only certain families (mother, father, children) and condemn other families (single parents, LGBTQ+ parents) and take political action to do so. That's abusive and sad, IMO. What a waste of resources.

I don't understand how gay couples marrying will destroy others' "traditional" marriage, but that's what I've heard from Church members.
-I've listened to Oaks' talk being quoted over my ward's pulpit about our religious freedoms being under attack (because we can't take away others' freedom?? Boo hoo). 
-I was so disappointed when I saw a picture in the newspaper of a rally held at the Capitol last summer fighting against gay parents ("Every child deserves a mother and a father!": there in the picture were several of my ward members and neighbors, people who I cared for hurting other people I cared for.
-My neighbor behind me posted on Facebook that she had started to understand the rationale of why people would support marriage equality. She had been hired to do some typing for a publication which supported it. While transcribing/typing the pro-agruments, the reasons made sense to her. Then she said, "BUT! I remembered I made a covenant to follow the prophet, and that's what I'm going to do." << So there it is. She trades logic, reasoning, and decency with following a prophet. That's cult behavior. 

Ultimately, the Church is using God as an excuse to further their agenda. Leaders of this church as well as other misinformed churches are products of ill-informed religious up-bringing where ideas about gay people are from a narrow interpretation of ancient scripture taken out of context, twisted to be more condemning during the Middle Ages, and passed down generation after generation with a threat of "don't ever question ecclesiastical authority or else you'll be in trouble with God" mentality.

3. What have you observed, first-hand, of the consequences of the Church’s actions, particularly in the political arena (e.g., Prop 22 and Prop 8 in California, and Amendment 3 in Utah) on individuals and families, whether positive or negative?

I've seen division and all types of relationships destroyed (family, peers, professional, political). I've also seen people leave the Church over this issue.
-Personally, I've lost TBM [true blue Mormon] friends after I became an advocate (BUT I've gained even better, genuine friends!). What I've gone through is mild compared to what others have experienced.
-A BYU-Idaho religion professor taught a friend's son and his class last year that anyone who supported marriage equality was a Satan figure. (Very divisive language and manipulation of young minds).
-I have an LDS friend who didn't know she had a gay son (13) while she and her husband obediently posted Prop 8 signs in their California yard and simultaneously announced how disgusting gay people were; he nearly took his own life to protect his parents from the shame of knowing they have a gay child.
-I have neighbors whose family members rejected them when they were supportive of their son who came out.
-It's not just TBMs becoming suspicious of advocates, but it's also advocates losing respect for those who fight against LGBTQ+ people's rights. (I have lost so much respect for many of my ward members, especially those who actively and blindly fight against equality without even getting to know the people they are hurting personally first).

The positive things I've observed from the LDS Church's involvement are awareness of the problems of discrimination, open dialogue to correct the problems, education, and progress. Seriously, if the LDS Church and its members hadn't been such ... such... I'm gonna say it: assholes, then I would have continued to be oblivious to the silent anguish the gay community has had to endure from prejudice, bigotry, discrimination, etc. The LDS Church's actions have brought the inhumane problems to the forefront so those of us with a conscience could do something about it. In my opinion, Props 22 and 8 as well as Amendment 3 made marriage equality a reality.

4. Tom mentioned your attempt to have The Miracle of Forgiveness removed from print.  Can you describe your attempts and any responses from Deseret Book or church leaders?

As I listened to the LGBTQ community (particularly the LDS LGBTQ community), a certain book title was commonly mentioned, President (apostle at the time) Spencer W. Kimball's The Miracle of Forgiveness as a source of much pain. One gay BYU student told me directly during a suicide awareness workshop that his first suicide attempt was about a month after reading The MofF. I was later told that this book was a standard in Mormon homes and that it's common for local leaders to keep copies in their office and hand them out to members who have morality issues. {Jump to a few months ago, 2014: an LDS friend of mine here in AF who had been pretending to be straight and in a traditional marriage came out to her bishop. He gave her a copy of The MofF. So, this practice is still being done.}

I purchased my own used copy for a dollar via Amazon to see what people were talking about. I was floored. In my opinion, that book has a lot of blood on its pages and is responsible for destroying families and lives. Of course, it's just a reflection of Church attitudes, but the fact that it's in a condemning book form solidifies the ignorance, making it that much more dangerous. I also noticed that the book contradicted the current Church teachings found in mormonsandgays.org. I thought that if I pointed it out to our leaders then they would take the reasonable and logical steps in correcting the problem. I had faith that the leaders would do the right thing ("Choose the right!"), apologize, and make amends. So, I did my research and formulated a long letter, personalizing each one in the greetings and intro. During the summer months of 2013, I sent out approximately 100 hard-copy letters to most of the Church presidency, apostles, and the Seventy. I also sent out a few to DeseretBook including Sheri Dew.

I had an inside friend give me the home addresses of some of the GA presidency members. Those were returned...opened.

Pres. Erying's (via his secretary) replied saying they are making note of my letter but that they have no jurisdiction over changing the book.

I never heard back from Dew, however, a Mormons Building Bridges leader had an appointment with her to discuss my letter and what steps can be taken to rectify the problem. Dew ended up canceling the appointment. It's my understanding that DB knows The MofF is a problem.

Here is a link to the letter in open-letter form posted on No More Strangers: http://www.nomorestrangers.org/the-miracle-of-forgiveness-an-open-letter-requesting-removal-or-an-update-to-reflect-current-knowledge/  This post also includes a comment section with some interesting feedback and dialogue.

I did hear back from Elder Ballard. He emailed August 21, 2013, asking me to call him. During the call (I would have to look up the exact date), I took notes then wrote the following down immediately after the call:

Well. It wasn't disastrous. I stayed calm and peaceful, not argumentative (I don't think I was). Focused. (Didn't ramble) I sense he isn't for Mormonsandgays.org (merely speculation -- he never came right out and said it). He kept steering me towards lds.org and the articles there {-- at that time, there was no link to M&G dot org from lds.org. I am told that there is a link now although I have not confirmed that}. At one point I said, "I'm sorry, isn't M&G an official Church website?" He confirmed it was.

He started off by saying the Church is not in a position to make changes to the book. And they aren't going to make any statements that would tarnish SWK's name. I followed up that I understood and that I would like to see the members to at least learn of what is said on M&G (that "SSA" is not a choice nor an illness).  "Oh, careful there. There is a lot of choice."

And this is when I realized I wasn't going to be heard. It appears he still thinks being gay is a choice. I listened and interjected. When he said we can't change doctrine, I asked if MofF was doctrine. Long pause. He answered yes and followed it with the parts that were (but I don't think he would say the "strong" words would be doctrine, that the way it was presented was Kimball's).

He seemed to avoid the idea of promoting what's in M&G. He has the stereotype in his head about what gay people are (called them "butterflies") and is convinced that "100's have been able to change their lifestyle."

This is the sad (sadder?) part. I brought up how our 13-14-15  year old gay youth and young adults feel unwelcome and are killing themselves. In my opinion, Ballard didn't validate their lives. "Oh, I don't know that there's that many." I said to him one is too many. He went on that there are other reasons for suicide: mental illness, drugs, and he listed more. (Complete denial, imo).

Regarding members' attitudes and hurtful speech towards "SSA" (I tried to speak his language). He agreed that members can get carried away and think they know what is taught and what isn't. I said that this book contributes to the hurtful talk towards our SSA brothers and sisters. He told me to keep doing the best that I can but to "be wise in my crusade." I said I am trying to support the official Church website and the kinder words there as apposed to MofF. He said stirring people up leads to bigger issues. (I don't know what he meant by that).

I bore my testimony and love for Christ, and that I am doing my best to follow him and his example and that this is why I wrote the letter and that I love my gay brothers and sisters.  I said it is never my intent to mislead or embarrass anyone (I didn't feel I did). That's when he warmed up (he was polite before, but not really warm). He was supportive of my character and said something like there's no doubt. He said, "We must love them the best we can." (Is it difficult? -- rolling eyes)

That's pretty much it. The conversation was filled in with the same type of preaching we hear at GC. I listened. I thanked him for his time. He asked about my family. I asked him about the water damage in his office (his secretary told me). He said my most important mission is my children, to raise them right. I agreed and said I am hoping for a kinder world for them to live in.

The last I saw, the book was still on DB's shelves. There was talk last year about beginning a letter campaign to remove the book from Church bookstores, but it was agreed that advocacy resources were needed for Utah's SB 100 and marriage equality debates.

{2015 Update: The Miracle of Forgiveness has been removed from DeseretBook bookshelves, although I can't vouch for each and every one across the country. Hopefully, they all complied}.

5. Have you had any comments from non-LDS friends relating to the LDS Church position on marriage equality?

Not too much. I've been pretty much in an LDS-world. I have a Baptist friend (attends weekly) in Oklahoma tell me she's fine with gay people marrying each other and that her church hasn't been condemning as far as she remembers (NOT the Westboro variety). She says her focus is more on the loving kindness of Christ's behavior and example and to treat others the way she thinks Christ would treat them (which is lovingly and respectfully).

6. Have you seen any changes in the way the Church deals with homosexuality as a topic, and with homosexuals as individuals?

Not really. I used to think that the Church's official website, mormonsandgays.org was a positive step in the right direction because it recognized that being gay (oops! "SSA") was not a choice, illness, nor something to be fixed. It also acknowledged that mixed-orientation marriages weren't typically a healthy choice. And it promoted kindness and respectful behavior towards our gay brothers and sisters. This is a huge improvement from The Miracle of Forgiveness rhetoric. But the Church has done very little to even promote its website. I believe some of the top 15 wish it didn't exist (Ballard being one of them). My Stake President was NOT aware that the website said right on top of its page that being gay was neither a choice, illness, nor something to be fixed. I had to point it out to him. (You should have seen the look on his face!) He's a good man, though. {The website, btw, needs to emphasize teens can be gay, too, and often know at young ages their orientation, whether or not they "act" on it. I also wish it didn't push celibacy for gay members who want to be active members. For a church to raise people to be family-oriented and say how great spouses and children are to then sentence a gay member to a lifetime of solitude if that member wants to be considered "worthy" aka "good-enough" is inhumane and imo, not something MY heavenly father would endorse.} The Church, as an entity, doesn't seem seriously interested in welcoming gay members. If they were, something positive (and direct) would be said during General Conference, like promoting their mormonsandgays.org website, for instance. Or denouncing the demeaning language in The Miracle of Forgiveness and apologizing* for it. 
{*Update: Elder Oaks has made it clear the Church doesn't apologize (link), which is counter to every lesson about repentance/restitution ever given. "Do as we say and not as we do."  See meme at bottom of this page}.

There's also no consistent counsel from the top about how to handle members who support marriage equality, gay members, trans* members, their families, etc. The member's outcome depends on bishop roulette. I've had fellow advocates lose their TRs, callings, and VT/HT assignments for doing less advocacy work than I have, yet I was still able to renew my TR, etc. all because I happen to have leaders that understand (after lonnnngggg discussions) that I have a right to vote my conscience. (Thank goodness that BYU-I professor wasn't my bishop -- he would have put a scarlet letter on me and label me a Satan figure!) Why do we (as a church) think it's okay for bishops and other leaders who have had NO legitimate psychology training to then counsel members about such personal issues? It's so destructive. 

{Update: 3 months after this interview, the Church finally counsels leaders that it's ok to publicly support gay marriage without fear of punishment from leaders. Link HERE}.

7. How have you seen church actions affect the national debate on marriage equality?


Oh, my goodness, their actions have helped marriage equality. Their whining about Shelby, Amendment 3, and religious liberty brought the debate out in the open. The public could see that the best arguments the Church (and Utah's Right Wing politicians) had to offer were weak and unkind.

Closing thoughts that may or may not pertain or interest you:
After beginning the GSA, I also saw a need for LDS moms with LGBTQ kids to have a safe place to find support and know they are not alone. I began the Facebook group Mama Dragon Council (Mama Dragon was coined by my friend Meg Abhau who said her protection for her gay son was stronger than a mama bear's and that she could breathe fire on anyone who dared hurt him). Here's a link to a story about the Mamas. http://www.nomorestrangers.org/when-religion-creates-dragons/

This last little bit is very personal. Only a handful a people know, and I hesitate to share it (especially if you are a Church member), but it's all part of the journey. This last summer I closed my FB account (found another AMAZING Mama Dragon to be the moderator) and had to take other steps to recoup. I felt like I was blind-sided during these past couple of years. The cognitive dissonance was heavy. Trying to "reason" and be "logical" with the Church was very disappointing. They aren't interested in reason and logic...nor truth. 

After some self-reflection this summer, a thought came to me, "When people use God as an excuse to hurt and manipulate others and claim they have the authority to do so, you better look at the foundation of that authority closer before going on in any direction." I did some research and investigating and discovered cesletter.com (which does a great job presenting both sides) and through that, mormonthink.com (another site that does a great job showing both sides). The conclusion for me is that the "authority" was built on sand, and I've been lied to. Although mad about the deception, I felt light and lifted. I officially cancelled my membership/removed my name from the Church. I was legally no longer a member by the end of October, and the Church finally confirmed it last week. Had Christ-like behavior (love, kindness, respect) been the Church's mission as well as accountability and transparency, had they apologized for destructive policies and made amends/restitution, then I may still be a member. I admire how the RLDS/Community of Christ owned their history and made the best of it. They embraced their history and foundation instead of hiding it, whitewashing it, rewriting it, and bullying others from learning about it.


I would be very interested in learning about your project and seeing it when you are finished. If any of my replies have prompted more questions, feel free to ask. Good luck!

Except for the mocking "Poison Oaks" part, this meme sends a very serious message.
A sincere apology needs to be given. The Church must set aside its pride.

Photo Credit: quotesfrenzy.com

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

My Conversation with Elder Ballard re The Miracle of Forgiveness

It's amazing what can happen within a year (since my last post): non-discrimination laws for LGBTQ+ in Utah, SCOTUS ruled in favor of marriage rights for gay couples. As for my life, I may elaborate another time. For now, I will say that the second GSA school year had some WONDERFUL members. They deserve as much attention here and from me as the first year's group, but I wasn't able to give that to them. Fortunately, they had their wonderful faculty advisors. <3

There are a few items I'd like to post in this blog even though it may not be directly related to the GSA. Nobody reads this anymore anyway, and it's convenient to keep these somewhat-related items altogether.

August, 2013, I wrote a letter to almost all LDS General Authority members including the 70. Many of them hard-copies, many in email versions. Most of the ones I sent to the top 15 were personalized. I also wrote to Deseret Bookstore and John Bytheway (for some reason I thought he was part of DB).
The letter was to request the removal of Spencer W. Kimball's Miracle of Forgiveness from Church-owned bookstores. Here is an open-letter version of my letter:

http://www.nomorestrangers.org/the-miracle-of-forgiveness-an-open-letter-requesting-removal-or-an-update-to-reflect-current-knowledge/

I struck a nerve.

Elder Ballard (one of the "twelve apostles") emailed me, requesting a phone call. I was so happy. I thought, "Finally! Someone is going to listen!" I took notes while speaking with him and then further wrote right after the conversation. What I wrote, as is, is below. I told very few people about this conversation because I  thought it really put him in a bad light; I was embarrassed for my spiritual leader. I share it now because it is what it is.

My conversation with Elder Ballard:
Well. It wasn't disastrous. I stayed calm and peaceful, not argumentative (I don't think I was). Focused. (Didn't ramble) I sense he isn't for Mormonsandgays.org (merely speculation -- he never came right out and said it). He kept steering me towards lds.org and the articles there. At one point I said, "I'm sorry, isn't M&G an official Church website?" He confirmed it was.
He started off by saying the Church is not in a position to make changes to the book. And they aren't going to make any statements that would tarnish SWK's name. I followed up that I understood and that I would like to see the members to at least learn of what is said on M&G (that "SSA" is not a choice nor an illness). "Oh, careful there. There is a lot of choice."
And this is when I realized I wasn't going to be heard. It appears he still thinks being gay is a choice. I listened and interjected. When he said we can't change doctrine, I asked if MofF was doctrine. Long pause. He answered yes and followed it with the parts that were (but I don't think he would say the "strong" words would be doctrine, that the way it was presented was Kimball's).
He seemed to avoid the idea of promoting what's in M&G. He has the stereotype in his head about what gay people are (called them "butterflies") and is convinced that "100's have been able to change their lifestyle."
This is the sad (sadder?) part. I brought up how our 13-14-15 year old gay youth and young adults feel unwelcome and are killing themselves. In my opinion, Ballard didn't validate their lives. "Oh, I don't know that there's that many." I said to him one is too many. He went on that there are other reasons for suicide: mental illness, drugs, and he listed more. (Complete denial, imo).
Regarding members' attitudes and hurtful speech towards "SSA" (I tried to speak his language). He agreed that members can get carried away and think they know what is taught and what isn't. I said that this book contributes to the hurtful talk towards our SSA brothers and sisters. He told me to keep doing the best that I can but to "be wise in my crusade." I said I am trying to support the official Church website and the kinder words there as apposed to MofF. He said stirring people up leads to bigger issues. (I don't know what he meant by that).
I bore my testimony and love for Christ, and that I am doing my best to follow Him and His example and that this is why I wrote the letter and that I love my gay brothers and sisters. I said it is never my intent to mislead or embarrass anyone (I didn't feel I did). That's when he warmed up (he was polite before, but not really warm). He was supportive of my character and said something like there's no doubt. He said, "We must love them the best we can." (Is it difficult? -- rolling eyes)
That's pretty much it. The conversation was filled in with the same type of preaching we hear at GC. I listened. I thanked him for his time. He asked about my family. I asked him about the water damage in his office (his secretary told me). He said my most important mission is my children to raise them right. I agreed and said I am hoping for a kinder world for them to live in.

And in case you are wondering: yes, it took a while, but the book is off DB's shelves. :) It's amazing what can happen within a year (or two).

Image Credit: Pinetrest


Wednesday, June 25, 2014

No More Strangers: A Difference of Opinion

Friend Thomas Montgomery, active LDS member, responds to a common statement (next paragraph). His answers are so important to understand especially if we want to lift up and strengthen the youth as well as society in general. 

He responds to his friend's comment, "I wish we could learn to stop interpreting one person disagreeing with another person’s beliefs or lifestyle as being hateful...[I]t hurts me when others are accused of being haters simply because they disagree with another person’s lifestyle or beliefs.  I have struggled to understand how one can interpret a difference of opinion as being hateful.”

Click here for the link:
http://www.nomorestrangers.org/a-difference-of-opinion/

Or read here:

Over the past few years, I have had dozens of conversations with friends and family members who are active members of the LDS Church on the subject of homosexuality.  Most active members feel misunderstood and maligned by the ‘world’ and the ‘liberal press’ and labeled haters.  My wife and I have encountered this sentiment first hand as the majority of the LGBT people we have met believe that Mormons hate gay people.  Beyond our anecdotal evidence is a recent Pew Research Study that revealed that Mormons are perceived as the second most unfriendly religion (worldwide) to LGBT individuals. (http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2013/06/13/a-survey-of-lgbt-americans/7/#feeling-unwelcome)

In our polarized political and social world, both the LGBT community and the Mormon community continue to speak past each other without genuine understanding.  Today I wanted to specifically help the Mormon community come to a place of better understanding.  Most Mormons I know try very hard to be kind and understanding.  They truly believe in attempting to be Christ-like to everyone.  Of course, the success of this effort varies widely from individual to individual, but on the whole they are very good people.

A friend of mine recently lamented, “I wish we could learn to stop interpreting one person disagreeing with another person’s beliefs or lifestyle as being hateful.  That feeling isn’t one any human being should ever be made to feel.  Equally it hurts me when others are accused of being haters simply because they disagree with another person’s lifestyle or beliefs.  I have struggled to understand how one can interpret a difference of opinion as being hateful.”

This line of thinking is very common in the LDS Church.  The incredulity of being hated for standing up for your beliefs is substantial.  And because homosexuality is so far outside of their life experience, it is like talking in a foreign language.  Here are some key points I want my Mormon friends to ponder and consider.

1)      This isn’t a simple disagreement over a personal preference.  People do not choose to be gay.  Whether it is biological or environmental in origin, being gay (or SSA) is an unalterable fact of life.  This is beyond debate as it is the conclusion of every major medical and psychological association in the country.  It is also accepted by the Church: “Even though individuals do not choose to have such attractions, they do choose how to respond to them.” (www.mormonsandgays.org)

2)      Your opinion takes everything precious away from me.  At a very fundamental level, our doctrine is devastating to LGBT youth and adults.  From a Mormon perspective, the only acceptable choices for someone who is gay are celibacy or a mixed orientation marriage (MOM).  This doctrine robs LGBT youth of hope.  It robs them of self-esteem and worth.  At best it tells you that you are broken and will be fixed in the next life.  It is a complete rejection of who you are now.  It tells you that unless you can change to a more worthy state (straight), you can never have the one thing that Mormons value most in life: family.

3)      There is no experiment you could devise that could duplicate the experience of being in the closet.  My son came out at age 13.  He was remarkably young.  He knew he was gay for probably less than two years before he came out.  In that time he suffered tremendously.  He was isolated and alone.  He felt hated by God and his family so much so that even suicide was an option.  As my wife said powerfully in the film ‘Families Are Forever’, “There is something not right with a 13 year old having to think that.”  For those of you who have suffered years and decades longer than my son, I can only imagine your pain and try to empathize.

4)      Sexual orientation is not cured through the Atonement. Many faithful LGBT Mormons pursue fixing and changing their orientation.  They become zealously obedience and faithful, many completing full-time missions with honor.  I personally know those who spend years and even decades dedicated to changing themselves, often to the point of self-hatred.  This dark path has also ended in suicide, extreme depression and drug abuse.  Best case scenarios result in an individual moving toward asexuality rather than completely reversing their orientation.

5)      Mixed Orientation Marriages (MOMs).  This is viewed as the gold standard of achievement for an LGBT individual raised in the Church.  While sexual orientation cannot be cured, some have been able to minimize their sexual attraction.  In a study of over 1,600 LGBT Mormons (the most extensive and current of its kind;http://ldshomosexuality.com/ ), 70-80% of those MOMs failed.  That’s an astronomical divorce rate.  Of those that succeeded, the gay spouses were far closer to a bi-sexual range than homosexual (as measured on the Kinsey scale).  Expecting and demanding this of all of our LGBT brothers and sisters is fraught with real danger.  There are straight spouses and innocent children involved.  President Hinckley specifically cautioned against MOMs as a cure or fix for homosexuality

6)      Celibacy.  Again, to end yet another prevalent assumption:  Celibacy is in no way comparable to being an older, straight single adult who never marries.  An LDS LGBT friend of mine said recently, “Single people pray every night to find someone to fall in love with.  Gay people trying to stay in the Church pray every night not to find someone to fall in love.” (Jamison Manwaring) Celibacy demands asexuality.  A straight single adult can date, hug, kiss, show affection for and pursue relationships.  A celibate LGBT youth or adult is shunned for showing any hint of affection for the same sex.  My Stake President was very specific to me regarding my son.  No activities that even encouraged same sex relationships are to be allowed or encouraged (Even holding hands).  Setting sex completely aside, we are forbidding someone from having what we find the greatest satisfaction in life.  Are we still just disagreeing?

7)      When have you ever expressed love to an LGBT person?  Our rhetoric is full of ‘love the sinner, hate the sin.’  I find it to be one of the most hypocritical and condemning statements that religious people make.  Because loving the sinner would require you at some point to have actually in some tangible way demonstrated love for the sinner.  We are condemned as haters by that same statement because there is no evidence of love.  I think back to Prop 8 in California.  There has been no outreach or effort of any kinds from the LDS community to the LGBT community in the past 6 years.  Just saying it doesn’t make it true.

8)      The stereotype of the “Gay Lifestyle” is an extreme born out of rejection.  The stereotype of the gay lifestyle is one of debauchery, lasciviousness, promiscuity, pornography and depravity.  The truth is that unlike the stereotype, every LGBT person I have met is remarkably….just like everybody else.  There is as much diversity among LGBT individuals as among straight people, but when you add in the devastation of being in the closet and the rejection of family and religion, you find a great backlash against those morals, principles and beliefs.  A backlash born of pain and suffering.  In the end, who is responsible for that pain and suffering?

9)      The true Gay Lifestyle.  I have met hundreds of LGBT people.  Most of them have Mormon roots and many still love the Church.  Many are doctors, lawyers, nurses, leaders, scout masters, store clerks as well as kids in high school.  They are as normal as you and me (even if some have a bit of flair and fabulous thrown in.)  They have normal life routines and very normal, loving relationships.

10)   Gay parents.  Again, I know hundreds of gay parents.  A few are in MOMs, many are amicably divorced yet still wonderful parents, and others are in same sex marriages.  I know a lesbian couple that I tremendously admire who have adopted 7 special needs young adult foster children.  We can hold to the ideal of one man and one woman all we want, but the truth is that two parents of any combination are more secure and stable than either one parent or no parents at all.

11)   Gay Marriage does not threaten traditional marriage.  The dangers to sexuality for heterosexual people are the same as those for gay people: debauchery, lasciviousness, promiscuity, pornography, depravity, etc….  These evils are alive and well in the heterosexual community.  In my children’s schools the majority of their friends are from broken homes.  But with contempt we point to the gay community as a threat?  Condemning homosexuality does nothing to improve or change the state of traditional marriage.  And because homosexuality is an inherit trait, there will be no more or less LGBT people in the future than there are now.  Our acceptance or condemnation does not influence how many LGBT people there are, but it would have a massive impact on their quality of life and life spans as they experience less rejection in their lives.

12)   I support Gay Marriage.  I don’t think I have ever written or declared this, but here it is.  The best way I can express this is by using the measure that Elder Oaks put forth in a General Conference talk entitled Good, Better, Best.  Here are my personal thoughts:

Current State of Affairs -
First, let’s take a moment to evaluate where we are starting from.  Currently, most LGBT youth and adults leave the Church. I am sure this is not a surprise or a point of debate.  Unfortunately, many of their family members follow.  In this article, I have put up no contention with policy or doctrine, but simply look at the fruit of the current state of affairs.  Statistically, highly rejected LGBT youth are 8 times more likely to commit suicide, 3 times more likely to be homeless, 3 times more likely to abuse drugs and 3 times more likely to get sexually transmitted diseases (http://familyproject.sfsu.edu/publications.)
We can stick to our guns and defend the Proclamation on the Family until we are blue in the face and it will not save one LGBT life.  Each political action we take further cements our reputation as the most unfriendly religion to the LGBT community.  We currently alienate and drive our LGBT brothers and sisters from our stakes.  At the same time, those who are rejected from among us are left to the mercies of the world and fall straight into all the stereotypes we sought to protect them from.  Are we perpetuating a cycle of unintended yet devastating consequences?

What would be Good -
Can we withhold judgment long enough to just let them be among us?  Can we acknowledge that perhaps this subject is infinitely more complex than we ever considered?  Can we not assume that ‘different’ is the same as ‘depraved’?

But while the Atonement is meant to help us all become more like Christ, it is not meant to make us all the same.  Sometimes we confuse differences in personality with sin.  We can even make the mistake of thinking that because someone is different from us, it must mean they are not pleasing to God.  This line of thinking leads some to believe that the Church wants to create every member from a single mold – that each one should look, feel, think, and behave like every other.  This would contradict the genius of God, who created every man different from his brother, every son different from his father. (President Uchdorf)

For some reason, our Heavenly Father has LGBT children.  I refuse to believe that the status quo is acceptable.  Many remark that the “Gay Agenda” is seeking to change the doctrines of God to accept their lifestyle and want a ‘comfortable God’ that demands nothing of them.  Are you so sure of your positon that you are willing see a 13 year old boy commit suicide because of it?  I advocate for LGBT youth (especially LDS LGBT youth) because my ‘comfortable God’ finds that unacceptable.  There is something wrong.  This has been confirmed via the Holy Ghost to my soul.  If you want to not be hated, stop acting like a victim and acknowledge there needs to be change.

But what is changing – and what needs to change (emphasis added) – is to help Church members respond sensitively and thoughtfully when they encounter same-sex attraction in their own families, among other Church members, or elsewhere. (www.mormonsandgays.org)

What would be Better -
My wife and I were privileged to meet with Elder Christofferson recently last year.  He listened to our story and that of our gay son and the hardship we have encountered in the Church.  He was loving and compassionate.  He cried with us.  He didn’t attempt to give excuses or marginalize our experience.  His simple instruction to us was to “lead with compassion”.  I think this applies equally for those seeking a place for LGBT individuals in the Church as well as those that would label people in the Church as ‘haters’.

As a church, nobody should be more loving and compassionate.  Let us be at the forefront in terms of expressing love, compassion and outreach.  Let’s not have families exclude or be disrespectful of those who choose a different lifestyle as a result of their feelings about their own gender. (Elder Cook)

Leading requires action.  Nobody should be more loving or compassionate.  Being at the forefront requires a desire to reach out and make a difference.  Being at the forefront in today’s world means having the fortitude to endure the criticism that is sure to come from every side.  To not exclude or be disrespectful requires an elevation in the dialogue.  Instead of recounting our polarizing positions, perhaps we could actually just listen.  Listen with the intent to hear, not with the intent to respond or judge.

Lead with compassion. (Elder Christofferson)

What would be Best -
What should the Church do with its righteous LGBT members?  Currently there is no distinction made in our doctrine/policies between:
1. A straight person who lives a life of debauchery, lasciviousness, promiscuity and depravity
2. A righteous LGBT person in a committed same sex marriage.
3. An LGBT person who lives a life of debauchery, lasciviousness, promiscuity and depravity

I don’t know how we can’t see the inequality in the application of morality.  Accepting gay marriage as an acceptable civil arrangement does not threaten temple marriages.  Such individuals should be allowed to be part of the body of Christ; our wards and our stakes.  We are poorer without them.  They should be able to partake of the Sacrament and worship with us.  They are as committed and moral as any straight people I know.  Many are spiritual giants waiting to be included in the Church and serve with us.

In this Church that honors personal agency so strongly, that was restored by a young man who asked questions and sought answers, we respect those who honestly search for truth. 

Sometimes questions arise because we simply don’t have all the information and we just need a bit more patience.  When the entire truth is eventually known, things that didn’t make sense to us before will be resolved to our satisfaction.

Sometimes there is a difference of opinion as to what the “facts” really mean.  A question that creates doubt in some can, after careful investigation, build faith in others.

And, to be perfectly frank, there have been times when members or leaders in the Church have simply made mistakes.  There may have been things said or done that were not in harmony with our values, principles, or doctrine.

I suppose the Church would be perfect only if it were run by perfect beings.  God is perfect, and His doctrine is pure.  But He works through us-His imperfect children-and imperfect people make mistakes. (Elder Uchdorf)

So, can we ask the question, “What should the Church do with its righteous LGBT members?”  Let us give hope to those who have little.  Let us show love to those who have been hated and despised.  Let us raise our dialogue to lift up the spiritually wounded and find a place in our congregations for our LGBT brothers and sisters.  And if we can’t achieve what is Best, can we at least raise our efforts to what is Good or even Better.

Image Credit: wheatandtares dot org

Pride Parade 2014

I had the immense pleasure to march in the Pride Parade with some of our GSA club members and faculty advisor.  We joined Utah Pride Center and other Utah QSAs and were one of the last to march (right before the giant rainbow flag). I was originally going to march with Mormons Building Bridges, so I just wore my MBB t-shirt as a compromise. We had a fabulous time!

During the march, a young man amongst the spectators held up a fabric banner which said, "Born This Way." I ran over to him and gave him a big hug, and he wrapped the banner around me and held me tight. I told him, "I know. I am so sorry. Thank you for being patient with us."

I really wanted to go to the festival and be part of the MBB "Hugged by a Mormon" booth. Due to some minor health issues, I was so wiped out by then and headed home. (Next year!)



Jimi Hendrix - Our club's mascot
who supervises our meetings.




Monday, June 2, 2014

Our Last Meeting of the School Year


The club members surprised the faculty advisors and me with a lovely plant, rainbow Skittles, a prom pic of all of them, and a card. This is what was inside my card:

Dear Gina,
Thank you so much for being our club mom. We have absolutely loved getting to know you. Your time, energy, and love are why we have the GSA. We wouldn't have been able to do it without you. Thank you for getting to know us and letting us get to know you. You are such an amazing woman. We hope you know that we all love you. The graduating seniors will definitely come back to visit you. You have changed all of our lives. Thank you again for everything you have done and continue to do. <3/ the first ever AFHS GSA 2013-2014

{Yes, this made me cry. :) }
Here's a pic of most of us during our last official GSA meeting.
And to think, we began this group wondering
if we would ever have our FIRST official GSA meeting.
They have accomplished so much. So proud of them.
The year went too fast. 

Friday, May 9, 2014

Queer Prom 2014


Utah Pride center hosts Queer Prom, a safe place for young people to have clean fun while being themselves. Our GSA group gathered themselves and took their own initiative to go (not a school-sponsored activity << disclaimer, LOL). I was asked to be the chaperone, and, oh, how I wish I could have (maybe next year). I absolutely love this group of people and will miss them so much (almost all are graduating). This has been a most-memorable, heart-growing year.

I'll answer some questions about the prom:

Q: Was there alcohol?
A: No

Q: Were there a bunch of people making out all over the place?
A: No

Q: What kind of music?
A: Mostly fast dancing songs. I was told there may have been one slow song.

Q: Were guys wearing dresses?
A: Yes, some. Gay guys, queer guys, and even straight guys were wearing dresses. [I wonder where in history and culture dresses (and make-up, for that matter) were arbitrarily assigned to females only? That would be an interesting study.]

Q: Do these socials teach you how to be gay? (Seriously, I was asked this question).
A: No. Being gay (or BTQIAP+) is not something you are taught nor "recruited" into... you just are (or aren't). Our straight GSA students are still straight. Our gay GSA students are still gay... but happy knowing they aren't alone.





Image credit: outyouth dot org